Download PDF by Edward Erwin: A Final Accounting: Philosophical and Empirical Issues in

By Edward Erwin

ISBN-10: 0262050501

ISBN-13: 9780262050500

More than a century has handed seeing that Sigmund Freud started his groundbreaking paintings in psychoanalysis but there's no consensus approximately his legacy; as an alternative there's continual confrontation not just approximately Freud's attractiveness and position in heritage yet in regards to the right criteria to take advantage of in comparing his thought and therapy.

This e-book develops epistemological criteria for Freudian psychology and gives a accomplished review of, and doubtless ultimate, verdict on Freud's idea and remedy. in contrast to the other evaluate released so far, it incorporates a systematic dialogue of either the Freudian experimental and non-experimental proof and the correct criteria for analyzing the evidence.

Part I considers the view that Freud's thought may be judged through specified evidential criteria deemed acceptable for judging hypotheses of common sense psychology. Edward Erwin argues by contrast view and for the employment of criteria appropriate to causal hypotheses of either the typical and social sciences. Erwin additionally addresses different concerns approximately criteria akin to the necessity for experimental facts, using placebo controls, the right kind objectives of psychotherapy, and using meta-analysis in reading final result data.

The criteria built partly I of the ebook are utilized in half II in comparing the simplest on hand Freudian evidence.

A Bradford Book

Show description

Read or Download A Final Accounting: Philosophical and Empirical Issues in Freudian Psychology PDF

Similar behavioral sciences books

Download PDF by R Mclaran Sawyer, Keith Prichard: Handbook of College Teaching: Theory and Applications (The

Faculties have gotten more and more excited about the standard of undergraduate guideline, and college are devoting extra realization to bettering their instructing abilities. This quantity can assist collage school increase their functionality within the school room. The publication includes valuable theoretical info at the studying types of students, and it offers useful info on how you can educate classes specifically disciplines.

Download e-book for kindle: Living Islam: Muslim Religious Experience in Pakistan's by Magnus Marsden

Renowned representations of Pakistan's North-West Frontier have lengthy featured simplistic photographs of tribal blood feuds, fanatical faith, and the seclusion of ladies. the increase to energy of the novel Taliban regime in neighboring Afghanistan improved the region's attractiveness as a spot of anti-Western militancy.

Download e-book for kindle: Culture: a problem that cannot be solved by Charles W. Nuckolls

French historian Alexis de Tocqueville saw that the clash among the beliefs of individualism and neighborhood defines American tradition. during this groundbreaking new paintings, anthropologist Charles Nuckolls discovers that each tradition contains such paradoxes, hence making tradition an issue that can not be solved.

New PDF release: The Psychopathic Mind: Origins, Dynamics, and Treatment

Forensic psychologist Reid Meloy identifies psychopathology as a deviant improvement disturbance characterised via inordinate instinctual aggression and the absence of a skill bond. it's the definitive publication at the topic. A Jason Aronson e-book

Extra info for A Final Accounting: Philosophical and Empirical Issues in Freudian Psychology

Example text

Nagel bases his second claim, that experimentation is generally unnecessary for the justiªcation of Freudian hypotheses, on a view about the justiªcation of commonsense psychological explanations and about Freudian theory being an extension of commonsense psychology. In speaking of an extension of commonsense psychology, one might mean that Freudian theory gains credibility from the empirical evidence supporting commonsense claims. , go far beyond common sense; in many cases, common sense and Freudian psychology are at war with each other.

Nussbaum says of this case (201) that Freud’s explanation consists of offering a redescription: What the patient was “really doing,” according to Freud, was restoring her husband’s honor, or protecting his pride. I shall return to Nussbaum’s contention shortly, but even if it is accepted without objection, my point remains: Freud was trying to explain the woman’s obsessional actions, but to do that, he ªrst had to identify them, and he did that without the help of a practical syllogism. Without support for this crucial premise—that identiªcation of an action always requires construction of a practical syllogism—Nussbaum’s entire argument collapses, for his conclusion that intentions are not causes depends on the assumption (196) that the connection between intention and action must be described by an analytic statement, which in turn is dependent on his initial assumption about the need to invoke a practical syllogism to identify an action.

By “degree of connection,” Hopkins means degree of meaning as opposed to causal connection. At least two problems arise with his conditions. The ªrst, and minor, one is that, on at least one natural reading of “coincidence,” we may rule out a coincidental relationship between events A and B, but be unable to discount the operation of some third factor causing B, or causing both A and B. We can avoid this problem by stipulating that ruling out a “coincidental” relationship between a motive and dream 38 Chapter 1 (or action) requires guaranteeing that the relationship is causal.

Download PDF sample

A Final Accounting: Philosophical and Empirical Issues in Freudian Psychology by Edward Erwin

by John

Rated 4.25 of 5 – based on 15 votes